Another closer is lost for the season in Ryan Madson, which means another pitcher will be elevating up to closer. The Reds are yet to name a replacement, but Sean Marshall is the best in-house candidate.
Marshall was acquired from the Cubs over the winter for Travis Wood and a couple prospects after becoming one of the best lefty relievers in baseball the past two seasons. Marshall had identical 2.50 xFIPs that resulted in 2.65 and 2.26 ERAs, respectively. His strikeout rate dropped last year from 10.9 to 9.4 K/9 but his walk rate also fell from 3.0 to 2.0 BB/9.
If Marshall is indeed named the closer, he would leap all the way up into the second tier in fantasy baseball. The only fly in the ointment is that Aroldis Chapman still doesn’t have a role and he’s having a dynamite spring. Chapman frankly deserves a rotation spot over Bronson Arroyo and Homer Bailey, but the former has a big contract and the latter has no options left. So Chapman will likely find himself back in the bullpen and maybe the Reds want to see if they can get a bigger return on their $30M investment than using him as a setup man.
A darkhorse but viable candidate is Nick Masset, who appeared to be the closer in waiting behind Francisco Cordero the past two seasons. But Masset walks too many (career 3.8 BB/9) and simply isn’t as dominant as either Marshall or Chapman.
The bet is that Marshall gets first crack at the gig, but Chapman could force his way into saves by blowing away hitters at a far greater rate than Marshall.